Beard Guyz Beard Serum vs. Wild Willies Beard Serum: Which One Actually Works?

In this article, we'll compare Beard Guyz Beard Serum and Wild Willies Beard Serum to see which one is the better choice. Keep reading to learn more!

We’ll cover how each product compares in:

• Ingredients

• Fragrance

• Price

• Efficacy

• Shipping & Returns

Key Similarities & Differences

Beard Guyz vs. Wild Willies: Key Ingredients

Beard growth oils include carrier oils, essential oils, and vitamin E. These ingredients can help to nourish your beard and promote healthy growth.

Beard Guyz Beard Serum Beneficial Ingredients

Beard Guyz Beard Serum contains 6 key ingredients that protect your facial hair from damage, hydrate your beard, and provide shine. 

Beard Guyz Beard Serum Key Ingredients

Beard Guyz Beard Serum’s full list of ingredients includes:

Water (Aqua), Glycerin, Tocopheryl Acetate (Vitamin E), Pisum Sativum (Pea) Sprout Extract, Chenopodium Quinoa Seed, Hydrolyzed Soy Protein, Hydrolyzed Keratin, Glycine Soja (Soybean) Oil, Hydroxyethylcellulose, Xanthan Gum, L-Arginine, Myristoyl Pentapeptide-17, Polyglyceryl-10 Laurate, Caprylyl Glycol, Ethylhexylglycerin, Phenoxyethanol, Sodium Benzoate, Citric Acid, Alcohol, Fragrance (Parfum), D-Limonene, Linalool.

Wild Willies Beard Serum Beneficial Ingredients

Wild Willies Beard Serum contains 14 naturally derived and organic ingredients that soften facial hair and skin, stimulate hair follicles, prevent beard itch, and help kill bacteria. 

Wild Willies Beard Serum Key Ingredients

Beard Guyz Beard Serum Potentially Irritating Ingredients

Beard Guyz Beard Serum contains ingredients that may cause an allergic reaction or dry skin. 

According to Decode INCI, the following ingredients may be irritating to your skin:

• Alcohol- “Works as an astringent but can be very drying”

• Fragrance (Parfum)- “Generic term that could be a number of ingredients”

• D-Limonene- “Allergenic”

• Linalool- “Skin sensitizer”

Wild Willies Beard Serum Potentially Irritating Ingredients

Wild Willies beard serum does not contain any harmful or artificial ingredients, making this a safer bet, specially for those with sensitive skins.

Winner: Wild Willies

When it comes to the ingredients category, Wild Willies is the clear winner. Wild Willies Beard Serum is the best option if you are looking for a natural growth serum or if you have sensitive skin. Beard Guyz Beard Serum consists of primarily natural ingredients, but there are a few ingredients that may be harmful to your skin. 

Fragrance

Wild Willies Beard Serum has a woodsy scent that comes from cedarwood essential oil. Wild Willies also has hemp beard oil that comes in 2 different scents. 

Beard Guyz Beard Serum has a citrus scent that comes from fragrance (parfum). Synthetic fragrances may cause allergic reactions and skin irritation. If you have sensitive skin, you will want to stay away from this type of fragrance. 

Wild Willies Options

• Wild Willies Beard Boost Serum

• Wild Willies Hemp Beard Elixer- Fresh Squeeze

• Wild Willies Hemp Beard Elixer- Wild Vanilla Spice

Beard Guyz Options

• Beard Guyz Beard Serum with Grotein

Winner: Wild Willies

Although both Wild Willies and Beard Guyz only have 1 scent of their beard serum, Wild Willies comes out on top since they use essential oils for their fragrance. 

Price

Wild Willies Beard Serum and Beard Guyz Beard Serum are both the same price, however, Wild Willies has better quality ingredients, including biotin and caffeine. So Wild Willies gives you more for your money. 

Winner: Tie

In terms of pricing, Wild Willies and Beard Guyz tie for the same price. Wild Willies offers more when it comes to ingredients, but they are both a great price. 

Efficacy

We have compiled feedback from over 60 different customers and came up with the most common pros/cons for both beard serums. 

Beard Guyz

Amazon Rating:

Beard Guyz Beard Serum is not very effective in growing facial hair. It does work well as a regular beard oil. However, it has a few ingredients that can dry out your skin, which has the opposite effect in promoting beard growth.

Some customers claim that it did not make their beard grow any thicker, but it helped their beard appear less patchy if they used the oil to style their facial hair.  

Wild Willies

Amazon Rating:

Wild Willies Beard Serum will help you grow a thicker, fuller beard in a short amount of time. Many customers suggest using the oil along with a derma roller in order to help your beard grow even faster. 

The main customer complaint is that the scent is really light, however, some customers liked that they could pair the oil with other beard products without the scents clashing. 

Also keep in mind that it will take at least 2-3 weeks for the oil to do its job and start affecting your beard growth. 

Winner: Wild Willies

Wild Willies Beard Serum beat out Beard Guyz Beard Serum when it comes to efficacy. Although Beard Guyz serum works well at taming flyaways and providing a pleasant scent, Wild Willies serum works better at moisturizing your beard and stimulating beard growth. 

Shipping & Returns

Wild Willies has a 100% money-back guarantee with free returns. They also provide free shipping on orders over $50. 

Beard Guyz allows returns within 30 days, however, you will be required to pay shipping and handling fees. 

Winner: Wild Willies

Both Beard Guyz and Wild Willies allow returns within 30 days, however, Wild Willies provides free returns and free shipping over $50. 

Conclusion: Beard Guyz vs. Wild Willies

Over-all Winner: Wild Willies Beard Growth Serum

Ingredients winner: Wild Willies
Fragrance winner: Wild Willies
Price Winner: Tie

Efficacy Winner: Wild Willies

Shipping & Returns Winner: Wild Willies

Both Wild Willies and Beard Guyz serum contain natural ingredients, however, Beard Guyz Beard Serum also contains ingredients that may cause skin irritation. 

Wild Willies uses essential oils for its fragrance, whereas, Beard Guyz uses synthetic fragrances. 

Wild Willies and Beard Guyz serums are both cost-effective. 

Wild Willies Beard Serum is better at stimulating beard growth and hydrating your beard, while Beard Guyz Beard Serum is better at taming your beard and providing a pleasant scent. 

Anything Else?

Comment below to let us know if we missed anything or if you would like us to review other products. Also, let us know if you have tried Wild Willies or Beard Guyz beard serum, and tell us what you thought. We would love to hear from you!

Beard Oil

$10.00

A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy. Experience the ultimate in beard care with Wild Willies Beard Oil, designed for badass beard care enthusiasts. Restores Moisture… Read More

Original - $10.00 Cool Mint - $10.00 Bourbon Cedar - $10.00

Learn More

Hemp Beard Elixir

$14.00

  Hemp Seed Oil contains the most natural source of essential fatty acids. Meaning it’s able to absorb easier into the skin leaving your beard feeling moisturized and nourished with an all-natural ingredient. … Read More

Learn More