If you're looking for a high-quality, all natural beard oil then you have two top choices- Dr Squatch Beard Oil or Wild Willies Beard Elixir.
Both products are made with natural ingredients and come highly rated, but which one should you choose? In this article, we'll take a look at the key differences and similarities between the two products to help you make an informed decision.
In this article we’ll cover:
-
Key similarities and differences
-
Ingredients
-
Available scents
-
Price
-
Plus, which oil is best for beard hair?
Table of Contents
Dr Squatch Beard Oil vs Wild Willies Beard Elixir: A Quick Take
Dr Squatch Beard Oil: Dr. Squatch's quirky brand is focused on bringing high quality products to the market. This means they are sustainably sourcing ingredients without any unnecessary additives.
They offer two oils, one contains a woodsy trio for a pine scent (crushed pine beard oil) and the other essential oils of sandalwood and citrus for a robust earthy scent.
Wild Willies Beard Elixir: Wild Willies is equally focused on high quality products with eco-friendly and organic ingredients. And giving you the best bang for your buck. Wild Willies beard oils are formulated in small batches with only the highest quality ingredients. They offer both a scented and a subtle "unscented” version that many men love.
The Overall Winner: Wild Willies Beard Elixir is the overall winner for providing the best value and good-for-you ingredients.
Key Similarities and Differences
|
Wild Willies Beard Elixir |
Dr Squatch Oil |
|
|
Key Similarities
-
Designed to moisturize the beard to help with growth and texture
-
Where products are sources from
-
Quality of ingredients with only natural essential oils
Key Differences
-
Price and size: Wild Willies is $9.86 for 2 ounces vs. $18 for 1 ounce with Dr. Squatch
-
Wild Willies beard Elixir offers original (sutble) and cool mint (fresh) scents, while Dr. Squat offers Crushed Pine (like fresh mountain air and Christmas morning) and Sandalwood Bourbon (with a subtle citrus undertone)
-
Wild Willies offers a convenient spray top, while Dr. Squatch crushed pine and sandalwood bourbon oil uses a dropper
Ingredients
Each product is made with only the best ingredients and natural essential oils.
Wild Willies Beard Elixir
Only the best Wild Willies ingredients are used exclusively in this mild mix, with no chemicals, sulfates, or other harsh irritants.
Let's review the included oils:
-
Grapeseed oil
-
Argan oil
-
Mauritia flexuosa fruit oil:
-
Prunus armeniaca (apricot) kernel oil
-
Castor seed oil (Ricinus communis)
-
Tea tree oil
-
Officinalis (rosemary) leaf oil
-
Jojoba oil from Simmondsia chinensis (jojoba) seeds
-
Juniperus virginiana oil
These hair and skin ingredients have all been carefully chosen for their benefits, including being packed with vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. This means your beard (and skin underneath) can both look better and feel better.
Dr Squatch Beard Oil
Dr. Squatch has the same primary oils in their blends, including jojoba oil, castor oil, and argan oil. These are the key oils that will hydrate your beard and skin. Additionally, it offers unique oil blends that offer both health benefits and a distinct scent.
These natural oils include:
-
Almond Oil
-
For the sandalwood bourbon beard oil blend: essential oils of sandalwood, bergamot, coriander, basil, vetiver, grapefruit, frankincense, and myrrh (smells like fresh squeezed oj and wood).
-
For the crushed pine beard oil blend: this composition contains a woodsy blend of essential oils of cedarwood, sweet orange, fir needle hemlock spruce, and patchouli (the perfect pine beard oil quantity to smell like Christmas morning).
Once again these oils, particularly almond oil, jojoba oil, argan oil, and castor oil, offer a variety of benefits for both the hair and skin, as well as a unique scent.
The Winner
This category is a tie. Both products use top-of-the-line ingredients and an earthy composition that are designed to offer both health and aesthetic benefits.
Available Scents
Wild Willies Beard Elixir
Wild Willies Beard Elixir comes in two scents: original and cool mint. The original will have a distinct scent based on the natural oils used. Customers report a pleasant natural and earthy scent that isn't overwhelming. You can expect cool mint to smell fresh and crisp.
Dr Squatch Oil
As mentioned, there are two distinct scents available with Dr. Squatch beard oil: Crushed Pine and Sandalwood Bourbon. These aren't standard fragrance products that are filled with perfumes and harsh chemicals that dry the skin. Instead, they are made of natural essential oils only meant to "nourish your impressive face."
-
The crushed pine beard oil contains the perfect pine quantity to reportedly to smell like Christmas morning. The woodsy trio of essential oils gives it a distinct smell of forest and mountain air. (Also reported as great to pair with a sturdy flannel shirt for a summertime spent embarking into nature or on daylong canoe trips.)
-
The sandalwood bourbon version is reported to smell like a mix of earth, wood, and fresh squeezed oj (from sweet orange). Sandalwood is a favorite time honored scent for natural men's products.
The Winner
It depends on your preferences. For a more subtle scent and earthy composition, try Wild Willies. For more distinct scents of mighty redwood with a subtle citrus undertone, or a woodsy time honored scent of pine for your "man mane," try Dr. Squatch.
$ 10.00 A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy.
Restores Moisture
Leaves your beard feeling soft
Leak-proof easy to use pump
… Read MoreBeard Oil
Price
Wild Willies Beard Elixir
This beard oil is a great deal. Offered at $9.86 or $8.87 with a subscription for 2 oz. That makes the value $4.93 per ounce. Plus, they offer free shipping on orders over $50 in the US.
Dr. Squatch Beard Oil
Dr. Squatch beard oil is $18 for 1 oz. That makes the value $18 per ounce. They also offer free shipping on orders over $50.
The Winner
Wild Willies is the easy winner here for the price per ounce and overall value.
Which Oil is Best for Beard Hair?
You want to make sure that your beard oil is made of natural ingredients, specifically oils that will help to hydrate your beard hair and make for a well groomed beard. Overall, both brands offer excellent choices for beard hair health.
All the oil found in the products reviewed above strive to add moisture for boosting hair follicle health. Best of all, none of these products strip moisture with unnecessary chemicals and additives.
Bottom line - Wild Willies Beard Elixir vs. Dr Squatch
Both products are excellent choices for a natural beard product and well-groomed beard (or as Dr. Squatch says, an "impressive face forest"). They offer a variety of benefits, top-of-the-line hair and skin ingredients, and unique scent options.
For this comparison, both are great options. The biggest differentiator is value. Hands down, Wild Willies Beard Elixir offers the best value.
If you have a preference for a particular scent, you can choose which type of scent you are looking for. Choose from fresh squeezed oj and mighty redwood (sandalwood bourbon blend), to fir needle and mountain air (crushed pine beard oil), to a natural scent and earthy composition (Wild Willies Elixir Original) or fresh minty scent (Wild Willies Cool Mint).
Let’s review the winner for each category:
-
Ingredients: Tie
-
Scent Options: It Depends- choose from crushed pine beard oil, sandalwood bourbon, or unscented
-
Price: Wild Willies
Beard Oil
$ 10.00
A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy. Restores Moisture Leaves your beard feeling soft Leak-proof easy to use pump … Read More
Have you used Wild Willies Beard Elixir? Or Dr Squatch oil? Or any of their other great products?
Let us know in the comments below!
