If you, or some you know, have a beard, then you know that keeping it groomed and looking its best can be a challenge. Beard balm is one excellent product you can use after removing dead skin cells with a beard wash to promote healthy beard growth, smooth flyaways, and reduce any itch.
In this blog post, we will compare Scotch Porter Beard Balm and Wild Willies Beard Butter.
In this article, we’ll cover:
-
Key similarities and differences
-
Key ingredients
-
Product scent
-
Overall value
Table of Contents
Scotch Porter Beard Balm vs Wild Willies Beard Butter: A Quick Look
Scotch Porter Beard Balm: With a focus on natural ingredients, this product is designed to moisturize and nourish beards. However, it also has hidden perfume, which can be harsh on the face.
Wild Willies Beard Butter: Made with only the finest ingredients, this beard balm will tame split ends, and reduce dandruff and itchiness, all while making your skin softer.
The Overall Winner: Wild Willies Beard Butter is the winner for no hidden additives that can be harsh on your hair and skin. Plus, it is offered in the perfect 2-ounce size so that you can use it generously but don't have to worry about expiration dates.
Beard Butter
$ 10.00
Looking to nourish & soften your beard, but don't want to deal with messy & greasy oils? Use a beard butter/balm. All the same benefits of beard oil with a matte finish and mild hold for styling. Restores moisture Leaves… Read More
Key Similarities and Differences
|
Wild Willies Beard Butter |
Scotch Porter Beard Balm |
|
|
Key Similarities
-
Both brands are dedicated to high-quality natural ingredients
-
Neither products contain sulfates, silicones, petroleum, parabens, mineral oil, phthalates, or synthetic colors.
-
Designed to tackle typical beard itchiness and flaking to boost growth and improve texture
-
Price: Both are valued at just under $5 per ounce
Key Differences
-
Size: Wild Willies is 2 ounces, Scotch Porter is 3 ounces
-
Scent: Scotch Porter contains synthetic perfume, Wild Willies offers two scents with no additives
-
Wild Willies specializes in beard care (vs general men’s care like Scotch Porter)
-
Wild Willies is proudly made in the US
Key Ingredients
Wild Willies Beard Butter
Key ingredients of this butter include:
-
Castor oil: for promoting growth and thickness
-
Shea Butter: for hydration and softening
-
Beeswax: for sealing in moisture
-
Argan oil: for shine and softness
-
Jojoba oil: for hair and skin hydration
-
Grapeseed oil: for addressing dry itchy skin
-
Tea tree, cedarwood, and rosemary: for promoting skin and hair health, plus a refreshing scent
-
Addition of eucalyptus and peppermint essential oils in the cool mint scented blend
There are three distinct ingredient types in this beard butter designed to give your beard a healthy look and feel. Shea butter for softening, beeswax for hold and shaping, and a blend of oils to nourish.
Ultimately, this equates to a smooth and pliable balm that helps with less itching, irritation, and flaking, fewer split ends, and promotes hair growth naturally.
Scotch Porter Beard Balm
Let's review the ingredients in the Scotch Porter conditioning beard balm:
-
Castor oil: for promoting beard growth and thickness
-
Shea butter: for hydration and softening of the hair
-
Safflower oil: for hydration and shine
-
Biotin liposomes: for growth and strengthening of the hair
-
Stinging nettle leaf: for hair follicle stimulation
-
White willow bark extract: for dandruff and itch relief
This conditioning beard balm sometimes referred to as beard gel, includes similar oils and butter. Plus, it also has the addition of biotin for hair strength (and to promote hair growth), nutrient-rich nettle to make your beard shiny, and white willow bark to help with inflammation and itch. This blend is particularly great for dry or coarse beards.
It's important to note that there is perfume on the ingredients list as well- which can be hard and irritating for some skin types and affect your beard's texture.
The Winner
Both products are designed to help with a thick growing beard. However, Wild Willies is the winner here for no hidden ingredients that could contradict all the potential benefits.
Product Scent
Wild Willies Beard
Wild Willies Beard Butter comes in two scents: Original and Cool Mint.
-
The original scent is a natural blend of cedarwood, rosemary, and tea tree (all with their own hair and skin benefits)- which gives it a woodsy smell. Plus, the tea tree oil makes it great for sensitive skin.
-
The cool mint scent is a mix of eucalyptus and peppermint essential oils- which has a refreshing smell that customers love.
Scotch Porter Beard Balm
Scotch Porter conditioning beard balm is technically unscented. However, the website describes its scent profile as a "masculine but floral blend of carnation, with subtle notes of sandalwood, powdery musk, and spicy undertones."
Since there are no essential oils in this balm with their own scents, the smell is primarily derived from a synthetic fragrance that is added.
The Winner
Wild Willies offers two great scents that are both free of hidden perfume.
Overall Value
Wild Willies
This beard cream is priced at $9.86 for 2 ounces (making it $4.93 per ounce). Plus, you can get 10% off with a subscription. You can also get free shipping on orders over $50.
Scotch Porter Beard Balm
Scotch Porter conditioning beard balm is priced at $14.99 for 3 ounces (making it $4.99 per ounce). You can also get free shipping over $50 and 15% off with a subscription.
The Winner
The overall value for these facial hair products is about the same. Many customers agree that 2 ounces is a great size for beard pomade to ensure that you get to use it all before its expiration date.
Bottom line - Wild Willies vs. Scotch Porter Beard Balm
Overall Wild Willies offers the best beard balm products for intense hydration and strong hair. They're great for beards of all sizes and any skin type. You can expect great smells and nourishing ingredients at an excellent price.
Let’s review the winner for each category:
-
Key ingredients: Wild Willies includes more nourishing oils, butter, and essential oils- making hair shinier and your beard soft
-
Product scent: Wild Willies has two great scents and does not add any synthetic fragrance
-
Value: It's a tie.
Thank you for reading!
Beard Butter
$ 10.00
Looking to nourish & soften your beard, but don't want to deal with messy & greasy oils? Use a beard butter/balm. All the same benefits of beard oil with a matte finish and mild hold for styling. Restores moisture Leaves… Read More
