Scotch Porter Beard Oil VS Wild Willies Beard Serum

Looking to keep your beard looking its best? With options like beard oil and beard serum, it can be hard to know where to start and what to choose.

For starters, you can check out Scotch Porter Beard Serum and Wild Willies Beard Serum. While these two products are both called a serum, you'll find they have a few key differences. So, which one is right for you? Keep reading our full comparison article to find out.

In this article we’ll cover:

• Key similarities and differences

• Ingredients that boost beard growth

• Product scent

• Overall value

• What is the difference between beard oil and beard serum?

Scotch Porter Beard Oil vs Wild Willies Beard Serum: A Quick Look

Scotch Porter Beard Oil: While marketed as a “serum”- Scotch Porter is more of an oil because of its focus on supporting a frizz free beard and enhance facial hair shine. 

Wild Willies Beard Serum: A true serum. Not only does it nourish hair with oils like jojoba seed oil, but it also contains caffeine and biotin to stimulate growth. 

The Overall Winner: When it comes to a beard serum, Wild Willies is the winner for its focus on beard growth. It’s not just another overpriced beard oil. 

Key Similarities and Differences 

Key Similarities

• Both brands focus on sourcing high-quality ingredients, including natural oils (like jojoba seed oils) to help keep the beard smooth

• No sulfates, silicones, petroleum, parabens, mineral oil, synthetic colors, or phthalates are found in either product

Key Differences

• When looking at the ingredients list, the Scotch Porter Beard smoothing beard serum functions more like a beard oil (see more below)

• Price: Scotch Porter is more expensive

• Scent: Scotch Porter contains synthetic perfume

• Wild Willies brand specializes in beard care and beard growth, while Scotch Porter has many toiletry lines

Ingredients That Boost Beard Growth

A true smoothing beard serum is designed to boost beard growth potential. While all beard care products can help support beard hair growth, serums should contain specific ingredients meant to enhance the health of the hair shaft and stimulate growth.

For this ingredient comparison, we will take a close look at each product to see if they are truly serums.

Wild Willies Beard Oil

For a proper comparison, first, let's look at the key ingredients in Wild Willies' beard oil and their primary function:

• Grapeseed oil: Moisturizing to keep the beard smooth and shiny

• Argan oil: A beard conditioner that naturally strengthens hair shfts

• Mauritia flexuosa fruit oil: Deep conditioning for keeping the beard smooth and soft

• Apricot kernel oil: Softening the hair follicles

• Castor seed oil: Moisturize and nourish hair

• Tea tree oil: Great for sensitive skin and acne

• Rosemary leaf oil: Enhancing hair and skin health

• Jojoba oil: Prevent and manage any beard split ends

• Juniperus virginiana: Combatting dry or inflamed skin

Wild Willies Beard Serum

Now, let's quickly review the key ingredients in their beard growth and smoothing beard serum: 

• All the same ingredients as listed above to act as a beard conditioner (exactly the same blend and benefits)

• Caffeine: For an energy boost and to stimulate hair growth

• Biotin: Support keratin infrastructure, which will help strengthen hair and promote hair thickness

Scotch Porter Beard Serum

Finally, let's look at what's included in the Scotch Porter smoothing beard serum:

• Avocado seed oil: Moisturizes and strengthens the hair shaft for a silky beard

• Jojoba seed oils: Prevent and manage any beard split ends

• Sunflower seed oil: High in vitamin E to support healthy hair growth

• Canola oil: Moisturizes and acts as a protective barrier for skin protection and keeping your beard smooth

• Perfume: A synthetic additive for scent

• Corn starch: A filler for increasing product thickness

As you can see, the Scotch Porter smoothing beard serum has oils designed more as a beard conditioner for keeping the beards mooth rather than a powerful beard growth enhancer. Let’s do a side-by-side comparison of ingredients:

The Winner

If you want a beard serum that actually stimulates beard growth, Wild Willies Beard serum is the only choice. If you want a high-quality beard conditioner (oil), Wild Willies is still the best choice for a formula free of perfume and fillers.

Product Scent

Wild Willies Beard Serum and Oil

Wild Willies Beard Serum has the same original scent as their beard oil. You can expect an all-natural woodsy smell with a hint of minty freshness, thanks to all the nice smelling essential oils that also support your beard shine.

Scotch Porter Beard Serum

Scotch Porter smoothing beard serum has a Miami Duppy fragrance. On the website, it is described as a sharp green floriental (a masculine but floral blend) with carnation middle notes and powdery musk base notes. Unfortunately, the scent is achieved with perfume made in a lab, which can lead to dry skin. 

The Winner

Wild Willies never puts synthetic fragrance in their products. They smell great the way they are and will reduce the risk of skin irritation and drying.

Beard Oil

$ 10.00

A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy.  Restores Moisture Leaves your beard feeling soft Leak-proof easy to use pump  … Read More

Original - $ 10.00 Cool Mint - $ 10.00 Bourbon Cedar - $ 10.00

Learn More

Overall Value

Wild Willies Beard Serum

This product is $9.99 for 1 oz. Plus, you can get 10% off with a subscription. Shipping is free for orders over $50 in the US as well.

Alternatively, Wild Willies Beard Oil is $9.86 for 2 ounces.

Scotch Porter Beard Serum

Scotch Porter smoothing beard serum product is $19.99 for 1.7 oz. They also offer a discount for a subscription (15%). Plus, free shipping for orders over $50.

The Winner

Wild Willies is the better value, especially when considering that they are selling a true serum. Most importantly, don't pay for a pricey serum that is more like beard oil.

What is the Difference Between Beard Oil and Beard Serum?

Beard oil has one primary purpose: to condition the beard and promote moisture. When the beard, and skin underneath, are adequately moisturized it can definitely enhance beard growth potential and promote hair thickness. Beard serum takes this growth potential one step further, with ingredients proven to stimulate hair growth. Ultimately, beard oil supports growth while beard serum boosts it.

Wild Willies Beard serum is a great beard growth product. Plus, it pairs well with their entire line of beard growth products, including growth gummies, shampoo, and conditioner.

Scotch Porter beard wash, beard serum, and beard balm (Stoch Porter conditioning beard balm) are all designed for nourishing the hair cuticle and keeping a soft and frizz free styled beard. They do not have any products specically designed for hair growth. 

Bottom line - Wild Willies Beard Serum vs. Scotch Porter Smoothing Beard Serum 

When deciding the overall winner, Wild Willies is a clear choice- no matter what product you are in need of. They never use synthetic fragrances, their products are affordable, and they offer a variety of growth-enhancing products. Not to mention, their products work great to improve the health and appearance of your beard.

Let’s review the winner for each category:

• Beard growth key ingredients- Wild Willies

• Product scent- Wild Willies

• Value- Wild Willies

For this comparison, the biggest differentiating factor is its purpose. The serum is created to promote growth.

Beard Oil

$ 10.00

A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy.  Restores Moisture Leaves your beard feeling soft Leak-proof easy to use pump  … Read More

Original - $ 10.00 Cool Mint - $ 10.00 Bourbon Cedar - $ 10.00

Learn More