Scotch Porter Beard Serum vs. Wild Willies Beard Oil: How Will They Compare?


5 minute read

With so many different beard oils on the market, it can be hard to find the best one. Today, we will compare Scotch Porter Beard Serum and Wild Willies Beard Oil to see which one is better. Keep reading to find out!

We’ll cover how each product compared in:

  • Ingredients

  • Fragrance

  • Price

  • Usability

  • Availability

Over-all Winner: Wild Willies Beard Oil

Wild Willies: Best for all beard types

Scotch Porter: Synthetic fragrances & overpriced

Key Similarities and Differences

Product

Price

Size

Bottle Type

Scents

Ingredients

Amazon Rating

Wild Willies

$9.86

2 oz

Pump

4

Natural

Scotch Porter 

$19.99

1.7 oz

Pump

2

Natural & Chemicals



Ingredients

Winner: Wild Willies- All ingredients are natural

                Scotch Porter- Made with synthetic fragrances

Wild Willies- All of Wild Willies Beard Oil ingredients are naturally derived and work together to keep your beard and skin healthy. 

Rosemary oil is the only ingredient that may be irritating to sensitive skin. However, it has many benefits, including stimulating beard growth and preventing acne. 

Scotch Porter- Scotch Porter Beard Oil is made with mostly natural ingredients but also includes synthetic fragrances. 

Fragrances (parfum) is a generic term that can contain multiple chemicals and can cause an allergic reaction or skin irritation. 

The only common ingredient between Wild Willies and Scotch Porter is jojoba seed oil. Jojoba oil is similar to the natural oils produced by your skin and helps condition and nourish your beard hair and skin. 

Wild Willies Beard Oil Ingredients

  • Grape Seed Oil

  • Argan Oil

  • Castor Oil

  • Gold Jojoba Seed Oil

  • Vitamin E

  • Cedarwood Oil

  • Tea Tree Oil

  • Rosemary Oil

  • Apricot Kernel Oil

Scotch Porter Beard Serum Ingredients

  • Sunflower Seed Oil

  • Canola Oil

  • Jojoba Seed Oil

  • Avocado Oil

  • Silica

  • Zea Mays (Corn) Starch

  • Fragrance (Parfum)

  • Isohexadecane

  • Ethylene/Propylene/Styrene Copolymer

  • Butylene/Ethylene/Styrene Copolymer

  • Tocopheryl Acetate

Fragrance

Winner: Wild Willies- Has 4 different scents from essential oils

                Scotch Porter- Has 2 different scents from synthetic fragrances

Wild Willies currently has 2 scents of beard oil which include their Original scent and Cool Mint. Wild Willies also has Hemp Beard Oil in 2 scents. 

Hemp oil is a type of cannabis oil that is rich in fatty acids, vitamins, and minerals to help moisturize your beard and skin beneath. 

Scotch Porter currently has 2 different scents of beard oil, however, they are made with synthetic fragrances. 

Wild Willies Options

Scotch Porter Options

  • Original Smoothing Beard Serum (Sandalwood & Carnation)

  • Miami Duppy Smoothing Beard Serum (Saffron & Licorice)

Price

Winner: Wild Willies- $9.86 for 2 oz

                Scotch Porter- $19.99 for 1.7 oz

Wild Willies- Wild Willies Beard Oil is only $4.93 per ounce, which is an amazing price considering the quality of ingredients. 

Scotch Porter- Scotch Porter Beard Serum is $11.75 per ounce, which is overpriced for the quality. 

If you are looking for a budget-friendly beard oil without compromising quality, then Wild Willies is the better choice. 

Wild Willies

Scotch Porter

  • Original Beard Oil $9.86- 2 oz

  • Cool Mint Beard Oil $9.86- 2 oz

  • Hemp Beard Oil $19.97- 1 oz

  • Beard Boost Serum $9.99- 1 oz

  • Original Beard Serum $19.99- 1.7 oz

  • Miami Duppy- $15.99- 1.7 oz

Beard Oils

Beard Oils

$ 11.99

AWARD-WINNING ORIGINAL BEARD OIL   Wild Willies one-of-a-kind beard oil is made of 10 natural vitamins and organic essential oils that condition and treat each follicle down to their roots. Our unique, easy to use, no waste, pump design enables minimal product usage… Read More

Usability 

Winner: Personal Preference

Wild Willies- Pump

Scotch Porter: Pump

Wild Willies Beard Oil Benefits

  • Smooths and softens facial hair

  • Prevents beard itch 

  • Promotes beard growth

Wild Willies Amazon Reviews





Scotch Porter Beard Serum Benefits

  • Lightweight Formula

  • Strong Scent

  • Provides shine

Scotch Porter Amazon Reviews



Both Wild Willies Beard Oil and Scotch Porter Beard Serum have a pump design, which allows you to dispense a drop at a time, so you are not wasting any product. 

Both beard oils have their own benefits, so it comes down to personal preference. Scotch Porter Beard Serum has a strong scent and provides a nice shine but does not work as well at taming or smoothing facial hair. 

Wild Willies Beard Oil has a pleasant, light scent and works better at hydrating and softening your facial hair and skin. 

Check out the Amazon reviews above to see how customers feel about each beard oil. 

Availability 

Winner: Wild Willies- More availability overall

                Scotch Porter- Only available at 1 in-store retailer

Wild Willies- Wild Willies is available at many in-store retailers, some even open 24/7. It’s also available on their website and Amazon as an Amazon’s Choice product. 

Scotch Porter- Scotch Porter Beard Serum is only available at Target and online. 



Brand

Wild Willies

Scotch Porter

In-Store

Walmart

CVS

HEB

Target

Best Buy

Target

Online

Amazon

Wildwillies.com

Zabiva.com

Amazon

Scotchporter.com

Groomingstore.com

Over-all winner: Wild Willies Beard Oil

Wild Willies: Best for all beard styles

Scotch Porter: Synthetic fragrances & overpriced

Ingredients winner: Wild Willies
Fragrance winner: Wild Willies
Price Winner: Wild Willies

Usability Winner: Tie

Availability Winner: Wild Willies

How did we do?

Leave a comment below and let us know how we did on this comparison or if we missed anything. If you have tried either Wild Willies Beard Oil or Scotch Porter Beard Serum, tell us which one you prefer. 

Beard Oils

Beard Oils

$ 11.99

AWARD-WINNING ORIGINAL BEARD OIL   Wild Willies one-of-a-kind beard oil is made of 10 natural vitamins and organic essential oils that condition and treat each follicle down to their roots. Our unique, easy to use, no waste, pump design enables minimal product usage… Read More

Hemp Beard Elixir

Hemp Beard Elixir

$ 14.99

Wild Willies Hemp Oil is one of our best products that you can put on your skin and beard to achieve the greatest results but is probably the most widely misunderstood. The Hemp name tends to throw people off, so… Read More

« Back to Blog