Best Shaving Cream Menthol


6 minute read

Some men prefer a shaving cream with a cooling factor. Shaving cream menthols are the perfect product for keeping your skin cool and irritation-free while shaving.

We've put together a list of our favorite shaving cream menthols to use when shaving your beard.

Our Overall Favorite: Wild Willies Shave Lube

Others to consider:

  • Every Man Jack Menthol Shave Cream

  • Jack Black Beard Lube

  • Kiehl's Ultimate Ultimate Brushless Shaving Cream with Menthol

  • Proraso Shaving Cream

Wild Willies Shave Lube

Overall Favorite

The Wild Willies Shave Lube formula uses antioxidant-rich, naturally derived caffeine to reduce redness and keep the skin looking and feeling fresh and healthy after shaving. The natural ingredients help you keep razor burn and ingrown hairs at bay while giving you a clean and refreshed shaved face. 

Consumer Review:

"I have used a lot of different shave lubes over the years, as my neck is sensitive to razor burn and ingrown hairs. Wild Willes Shave Lube is by far the best I have found to stop the issues I had found with other lubes and creams. Great product!"

Pros

  • Uses natural ingredients, free of harsh chemicals and fragrance

  • Helps to alleviate razor burn and ingrown hairs

  • Infused with Eucalyptus and Jojoba Oil to soothe the skin

Things to Consider

  • Only one size option

Best Feature

Formulated with caffeine to help energize and soothe the skin.

Price & Rating

  • Price: $9.86 for a 5 oz. Bottle

  • Rating: 5 ⭐️ (18 reviews)

SHAVE LUBE

SHAVE LUBE

$ 6.88

The Ultimate Shave  Lube Fortified with the highest quality ingredients, Wild Willies Shave Lube utilizes Caffeine, along with Jojoba and Eucalyptus, to liven up your morning grooming routine and boost your shave game. Shave Lube promotes the benefits of antioxidant… Read More

Every Man Jack Menthol Shave Cream

The Every Man Jack Menthol Shave Cream is a suitable choice for all skin types, due to it's natural and clean ingredients. It is designed to hydrate and soften the skin to prepare it for a smooth shave, free from razor burn.

"I normally don't bother with shave cream, but this product is well worth the money. My shave is much more comfortable and closer than I have been used to."

Pros

  • Uses natural ingredients to moisturize, soothe, and protect the skin

  • Gluten-free and vegan friendly

Things to Consider

  • Contains fragrance

Best Feature

Uses natural menthol and caffeine to energize and cool the skin.

Price & Rating

  • Price: $9 for 6.7 fl. oz. Bottle and $3 for a 1.5 fl. oz. Travel Size Bottle

  • Rating: 4.7 ⭐️ (101 reviews)

Jack Black Beard Lube

The Jack Black Beard Lube is a 3-in-1 translucent formula. It is a pre-shave oil, shaving cream, and skin treatment all in one bottle. It uses menthol, peppermint, and eucalyptus oil to provide a cooling and tingling sensation to the skin.

"I use this to shave my head and around my beard. Love that it is clear so I can see my beard line and a little goes a long way. Thus large bottle will last me more than a year easily."

Pros

  • 3-in-1 formula 

  • Available in 4 size options - 3, 6, 16, and 33 fl. oz.

  • Vegan and free of synthetic fragrance, colorants, and parabens

Things to Consider

  • Higher price range

Best Feature

The 3-in-1 formula makes it easy to hydrate and soothe the skin while avoiding irritation.

Price & Rating

  • Price: Ranges from $13 - $64 for 3, 6, 16, and 33 fl. oz. Bottles

  • Rating: 4.8 ⭐️ (185 reviews)

Kiehl's Ultimate Brushless Shaving Cream with Menthol

The Kiehl's Ultimate Shaving Cream is suitable for all skin types and the brushless formula makes it easy to prep the skin for a close shave. Its key ingredients - menthol, camphor, and sesame oil - make it so your skin feels refreshed, cooled, and moisturized after shaving.

"This face wash is the only one that will clean my face and not leave it dry. I’ve tried several others and nothing has left my face as clean and healthy looking as does Kiehls."

Pros

  • Paraben and fragrance-free

  • Good for all skin types

Things to Consider

  • Higher price point

Best Feature

It is formulated to be suitable for all skin types. 

Price & Rating

  • Price: Ranges from $10 - $25 for 2.5, 5, and 10.1 fl. oz. Bottles

  • Rating: 4.5 ⭐️ (1139 reviews)

Proraso Shaving Cream

The Proraso Refreshing Shaving Cream is suitable for all skin and beard types. Its refreshing formula contains Menthol and Eucalyptus Oil for cleansing and toning, while simultaneously cooling and revitalizing the skin.

"The cream is moist, slick and effective, allowing for a very close shave. The scent, which blends eucalyptus and menthol, is bracing and, after a time, almost addictive."

Pros

  • No parabens, phthalates, silicones, mineral oils, artificial colors or SLS

  • 91% naturally sourced ingredients

  • Good price point

Things to Consider

  • Contains artificial fragrance

Best Feature

It contains Eucalyptus Oil, which cleanses and tones the skin while shaving.

Price & Rating

  • Price: $10 for 5.2 oz.

  • Rating: 5 ⭐️ (37 reviews)

How to Pick the Best Shaving Cream Menthol

Not every shaving menthol is cut from the same cloth. Each shaving cream will have different levels of menthol and cooling intensity, and it's important to know what you will like and what your skin can tolerate. 

These are a few things we think you should keep in mind when buying a shaving cream menthol:

1. Start by looking at ingredients. This is really important because, depending on your skin type, certain ingredients can be irritating to your skin. Stay away from shaving creams that have harsh chemicals. Look for one that has natural ingredients that will lubricate and soothe the skin, like Eucalyptus Oil and Aloe Vera, for a nice clean shave.

2. Consider the application preference. Some shaving creams are made to be applied with a brush or by hand. This is a personal preference and you should find one that suits your needs.

3. Consider the scent. The scent is also a personal preference, but you'll want to find something that has a scent you'll enjoy. We recommend opting for one that has scent from a natural source, and not from an artificial fragrance. 

The Bottom Line

Our Top Pick: Wild Willies Shave Lube

Wild Willies Shave Lube is our all-around favorite shaving cream menthol. It uses natural ingredients and no harsh chemicals so that your skin feels refreshed and energized after shaving. It's suitable for all skin types and is at a great price point. 

Other products worth considering:

  • Every Man Jack Menthol Shave Cream

  • Jack Black Beard Lube

  • Derby Shaving Cream Menthol

  • Proraso Shaving Cream

SHAVE LUBE

SHAVE LUBE

$ 6.88

The Ultimate Shave  Lube Fortified with the highest quality ingredients, Wild Willies Shave Lube utilizes Caffeine, along with Jojoba and Eucalyptus, to liven up your morning grooming routine and boost your shave game. Shave Lube promotes the benefits of antioxidant… Read More

« Back to Blog