Best Beard Wash: Wild Willies vs. Jack Black Beard Wash

8 minute read

Jack Black and Wild Willies are two popular beard brands. Each has its own unique take on what a beard wash should be, but which is the superior product?

We've put these two brands to the test and compared their differences so you can decide which is right for you! We will look at:

  • Distinguishing Features

  • Key ingredients

  • Fragrance Options

  • Price Differences

Our quick take: 

Over-all Winner: Wild Willies Beard Wash -  More naturally derived ingredients and covers all the bases as it moisturizes, smooths, AND volumizes your beard.

Every Man Jack: Really good product, and more of an all-in-one rather than solving your specific beard needs. 

Now let’s dive in!

Wild Willies Beard Wash

Beards trap dirt and grease, so they need a little extra attention to remain clean and healthy. Wild Willies beard wash is not an ordinary beard shampoo that might be harsh on your skin. It's tough on dirt but gentle on your skin and beard. With moisturizing and hydrating properties, it restores your skin while stimulating beard growth, and leaves you with a subtle tingling sensation.

Jack Black Beard Wash

Jack Black's wash is a multifunctional formula that helps cleanse, condition, and soften facial hair and hair follicles. A one-stop for men who might have less time for beard grooming but still want a quality product. With seventeen years of experience under their belt, it's no wonder why Jack Black beard wash is a solid competitor.

Distinguishing Features

Wild Willies

The Wild Willies beard wash has a number of features that make it a top choice in the world of beard washes - it moisturizes, smooths, AND volumizes. This is ideal for those who want a soft, easily managed, and fluffy (but not frizzy) beard. Who doesn't want that?

While all of these features already make the Wild Willies Beard Wash great, one key feature that really makes it stand out amongst its competition? The unique regrowth formula. Whether you're starting your beard growth journey, struggling with some patchiness, or just want to ensure your beard continues to grow fuller and healthier, Wild Willies' hair-stimulating properties are perfectly designed for you.

Jack Black

One key feature of Jack Black's beard wash is that it is a 2-in-1 formula. Not only does it clean your beard, but it also conditions it. This is a great feature for those who want to save time or who might be new to the world of beard care.

While the Jack Black beard wash moisturizes and smoothes, its gentle ingredients clean your beard without stripping away natural oils.

Winner: Wild Willies

Both products moisturize and smooth, which helps keep your beard tame and looking its best. 

What makes Wild Willies stand out above the Jack Black beard wash is the regrowth formula. Many men struggle with facial hair patchiness, and that's the last thing you want when trying to grow a full luscious beard. It's also ideal for those just starting their beard growth journey.

Key Ingredients

Wild Willies Beard Wash

Jack Black Beard Wash

  • Natural Ingredients

  • Vitamin E

  • Biotin

  • Essential Oils - eucalyptus, peppermint, and lemongrass

  • No chemicals, preservatives & colorants (if possible)

  • Jojoba Protein

  • Panthenol (Vitamin B5)

  • Aloe Leaf Juice Powder

  • Shea Butter

  • Vegan and free of synthetic fragrance, colorants, and parabens.

Wild Willies

Wild Willies focuses on clean products. Yes, they clean your beard, but they are also made of clean and natural ingredients whenever possible. 

A key ingredient in the Wild Willies beard wash is Vitamin E. This vitamin has a plethora of benefits, one of which is stimulating hair growth. In addition to that, it is an antioxidant that can help protect your skin from free radical damage. Another active ingredient this wash has is Biotin, which is used as a supplement to help with hair growth.

Essential oils are used not only to add a pleasant scent to the product but also have multiple benefits for your hair and skin. 

Peppermint essential oil is known for its cooling sensation, which can help soothe irritated skin. 

Meanwhile, eucalyptus essential oil has antimicrobial properties, which can help keep your beard free of bacteria. 

Lemongrass essential oil is known for its ability to stimulate hair growth. These natural oils help keep your beard soft while moisturizing the skin underneath without drying it out.

Jack Black

Jack Black beard wash contains many clean ingredients and is also cruelty-free.

Aloe vera is one of the key ingredients on the list for Jack Black's wash. Aloe vera is a great choice for those with sensitive skin as it is gentle and calming.

It also uses jojoba oil, shea butter, and panthenol. These help to add moisture to your hair and skin, which can help to prevent skin irritation and is great for those with coarse beard hair. Panthenol is also known for its ability to help repair damaged hair.

Winner: Draw

Unlike other beard shampoos and washes, both of these products are sulfate-free and paraben-free and focus on being clean and cruelty-free. Both companies have a strong focus on using all-natural ingredients - making sure the customer looks good and has a healthy beard.

They also both use ingredients to help moisturize and soften the skin and beard hair. Because of this, they are both great at helping those who have coarse facial hair or suffer from beard dandruff.

Jack Black's use of aloe and vitamins is ideal for those with sensitive or dry skin. The use of essential oils in Wild Willies beard wash is a nice additive because, in addition to the many health benefits, they also leave your facial hair smelling good.


Wild Willies: Cool Mint

Wild Willies' wash is scented, but not with alcohol or synthetic fragrances.

The Cool Mint smell is created by the use of essential oils to create a scent that is perfect for starting your day. It's not overpowering, so you won't have to worry about it being too strong for you or those close to you.

The combination of eucalyptus, peppermint, and lemongrass creates a refreshing smell that will leave you feeling invigorated and refreshed.

Jack Black: Unscented

The Jack Black wash is unscented, which some men prefer. The ingredients do lend to a light herbal scent, but there are no additives that make it intentionally fragrant.

Scents can sometimes clash with colognes or other products you might use, so an unscented option is always nice to have.

If you are someone who is sensitive to smells or who doesn't like heavily scented products, this might be the better choice for you.

Winner: Draw

It depends on your preference when it comes to scents. Both of these products are safe to use and don't contain any synthetic fragrances or alcohols.

If you are sensitive to smells, the Jack Black is probably a better choice for you. However, if you like to start your day with a refreshing smell, the Wild Willies is a great option.


Wild Willies: $13.00

This beard wash comes in a 4-ounce bottle and averages around $13.00 per bottle or $3.25 per ounce. This and other Wild Willies products can be found at retailers such as Walmart and Target, or shipped directly from the Wild Willies website.

Jack Black: $18.00

The Jack Black beard wash retails for around $18.00 for a 6-ounce bottle or $3.00 per ounce. The beard wash, as well as other products, can be purchased at Walmart and Ulta, or online from Jack Black's website.

Winner: Wild Willies

Wild Willies' product, while smaller in size and slightly more expensive if you compare the per-ounce price, has specific purposes and unique ingredients to match those purposes. The product will last longer over time, meaning you'll have to restock less often.

With a targeted wash, beard conditioner, and other products like beard oil and beard butter, you have one product for each specific need, which means you get more products and less frequent purchases.

Who has the best product: Wild Willies vs. Jack Black beard wash?

Who is awarded the title of best beard shampoo will depend on both your skin and hair needs, as well as overall preferences. Both Wild Willies and Jack Black have great beard and face wash and other beard grooming products. Product reviews are great for both Wild Willies and Jack Black, with 4.6 and 4.7 out of 5 stars, respectively.

If you are looking for an all-in-one product that is convenient and easy to use, the Jack Black beard wash is a great choice.

On the other hand, if you are looking for a more targeted approach with unique ingredients, the Wild Willies line might be a better fit for you.

Over-all Winner: Wild Willies Beard Wash

Wild Willies: Best for every day use including growth. 

Every Man Jack Beard Wash: A very good product that is more of an all-in one than supporting growth. 

Distinguishing Key Features: Wild Willies
Key Ingredients: Draw
Fragrance Options: Draw

Price Differences: Wild Willies

We would love to hear from you – let us know in the comments what you love in a beard wash and which features are important to you!

« Back to Blog